The 2019 Scholarly Communication Institute was held from October 13 to October 17, and this year’s theme was “Equity in Scholarly Communication”.
Five teams convened to work on projects they proposed in the spring, and to work across teams to better understand the structural and situational issues that present challenges to a more equitable scholarly communication and publishing ecosystem. During the course of the institute they explored ideas, developed initiatives, and launched projects aimed at promoting positive change.
Once the five days of the Institute, we collected highlights in the blog post below – featuring tweets, photos, links, and other information that reflect what was going on at the Institute.
You can join in the conversation too. Each year many SCI participants have been active on Twitter during the program, using the #TriangleSCI hashtag. Follow along there or in this list gathering tweets from the SCI 2019 cohort, send us questions, give us your suggestions, and engage with us as we further develop and implement ideas and projects.
If you’re interested in participating in person in SCI 2020, look for the next theme and request for proposals on this site in January. We’re happy to announce that we’ve received funding from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation to continue TriangleSCI for three more years. We’re grateful to the Mellon Foundation for their ongoing support of this program, and look forward to 90+ more people being able to participate in the next 3 years!
Thrilled to announce that the Triangle Scholarly Communication Institute #TriangleSCI has received funding for 3 more years, and grateful as always to the @MellonFdn for their ongoing support for this program. https://t.co/YvMjFjonD7 RFP for SCI 2020 coming in January!
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 3, 2019
Such good news and one of the things that makes working in this region so rewarding. And selfishly, I get to have some of the wisest, most provocative and imaginative folks in the scholcomm world delivered to our doorstep. https://t.co/W86HREVxXE
— John Sherer (@jesherer) October 3, 2019
The 2019 Scholarly Communication Institute starts on Sunday! Safe travels to everyone joining us in Chapel Hill, and we hope others will engage with us via the #TriangleSCI hashtag once things get underway. Highlights from each day will be posted here: https://t.co/hy6VYFRXAC
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 11, 2019
Will there be one next year? I keep wanting to apply to this, especially when they had storytelling as the theme.
— Jade Alburo (@JadeLibrarian) October 13, 2019
Yes, there will be one next year! Look out for the RFP in January. May want to follow @TriangleSCI – https://t.co/Lxbzq8HBUH .
— Patricia Hswe (@pmhswe) October 13, 2019
Excited to be in Chapel Hill for #TriangleSCI 2019! Four days of work and discussion about equity in scholarly communication. Feeling very lucky to have gotten a spot. This may be my first non-sarcastic tweet ever. pic.twitter.com/4ot9iQuNFm
— Rich Abdill (@richabdill) October 13, 2019
Hope you all have fun! I miss SCI
— Martin Paul Eve (@martin_eve) October 13, 2019
#TriangleSCI is ready to begin! pic.twitter.com/mlReIg4FUm
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 13, 2019
Kicking off the 2019 #TriangleSCI with @trln_main's Executive Director Lisa Croucher. pic.twitter.com/9x2V2VxFWD
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 13, 2019
Framing 2019 @TriangleSCI discussion with @csugimoto #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/p7RVbXqIru
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 13, 2019
Kicking off the #TriangleSCI meeting is 🌟 @csugimoto talking about the theme of this year equity (or better the lack of) in scholarly communication. pic.twitter.com/JSwlEPazc2
— Daniela Saderi, PhD (@Neurosarda) October 13, 2019
Cassie Sugimoto Prof of Informatics @IndianaUniv @csugimoto kicks off @TriangleSCI #Equity What can we do? #TriangleSCI Watch this space Thanks @MellonFdn pic.twitter.com/VD0d6ZkE0s
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 13, 2019
Gatekeepers for #scholcom have a huge impact on which scholarship passes peer review based on gender, nationality, language. @csugimoto #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/SjfDga7HhQ
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 13, 2019
English has taken a sharp upturn as the lingua franca of research over the past decade – Cassidy Sugimoto #TriangleSCI
— sspilka (@sspilka) October 13, 2019
Prof Sugimoto @csugimoto highlights Why #equity matters in Scholarly Communications. 70% of new journals created in English even in countries outside of U.S. Significant disparities by race of citation. #TriangleSCI #OA pic.twitter.com/RadLnxccse
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 13, 2019
Siiiii @HDCAICYT @yoko_nh @rominickyDL @ivonnelujano #trianglesci empieza con grandes lecciones pic.twitter.com/mdob9jIZin
— Gimena del Rio Riande 💚 (@gimenadelr) October 13, 2019
Great discussion about open platforms and acquisition by for-profit bad actors with @csugimoto, @lesliekwchan, and others at #TriangleSCI. pic.twitter.com/nE8k6wL7Vo
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 13, 2019
Thanks to @paoloman for the opportunity to join the kickoff for the 2019 #TriangleSCI meeting. Great projects on the theme of "Equity in Scholarly Communication": https://t.co/1lsBWXagjl Watch this space! @AprilHathcock @tceles_B_hsup @lesliekwchan @jesherer https://t.co/ISHrkhOKyl
— Cassidy R. Sugimoto (@csugimoto) October 14, 2019
A few photos from the #TriangleSCI opening reception, remarks, and introductions. pic.twitter.com/odqggCTCxT
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 14, 2019
I have been to two of them and can say that they were both two of the best years in my academic life. Enjoy!
— Dene Grigar (@dgrigar) October 14, 2019
Thank you Paolo for being the rainmaker! Such overdue conversation about equity, rather the lack of, in scholarly communications. @csugimoto was brilliant in setting the stage for us over the next few days. https://t.co/VrYobi1DYe
— Leslie Chan (@lesliekwchan) October 14, 2019
Lucky to be here for the first time. Off to a great start this evening. Paolo's land acknowledge was specially moving. Set a great tone for this gathering, as @AprilHathcock aptly noted.
— Leslie Chan (@lesliekwchan) October 14, 2019
I’m so excited to officially be part of the Triangle and be able to observe/support Triangle SCI from up close! My week at SCI in 2015 formed much of the work I’m still doing today. https://t.co/XhLNJEqlfj
— Micah Vandegrift (@micahvandegrift) October 14, 2019
Starting day one at #TriangleSCI at the @RizzoCenter in Chapel Hill, NC. Foggy morning but sun is bright. pic.twitter.com/tIWK3imcsS
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 14, 2019
Kicking off day 1 of team time with logistics from @paoloman at 2019 #TriangleSCI. pic.twitter.com/sVOIx7P0Jr
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 14, 2019
So inspiring. @TriangleSCI @paoloman Day 1 # #TriangleSCI #OA #Equity #FeministToolkit #EthicsofCare pic.twitter.com/75d4BQNKWc
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 14, 2019
Getting started at the Triangle Scholarly Communication Institute. #FeministToolkit #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/L5ekEyca7N
— OSU Copyright (@OSUCopyright) October 14, 2019
I'm at #TriangleSCI this week with my team @FarbThink @AprilHathcock @CopyrightLady pic.twitter.com/F2m7ibD6FF
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 14, 2019
Also of course if such a thing does not already exist, I would appreciate the contribution of schemas so that we can build said bibliography. #TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 14, 2019
This is the week when @aupresses folks might want to follow the #TriangleSCI hashtag. This year's theme on Equity in Scholarly Communications is going to generate a lot of original and ground-breaking ideas. https://t.co/xWOpGN6j3Z
— John Sherer (@jesherer) October 14, 2019
Our #trianglesci project is “the labor of open” but what if we called it “the capital of open” instead. 🤔
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 14, 2019
The Labor of Open group is building big ideas at #TriangleSCI. https://t.co/IV9YOcc6f2 pic.twitter.com/ugopiMFfaz
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 14, 2019
#FeministToolkit #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/SzYvPW0M6b
— Copyright Lady (@CopyrightLady) October 14, 2019
#TriangleSCI Excited to get to work on anti-racism Toolkits for Equity to support people of color, allies/coworkers & orgs to transform scholarly publishing communities – guided by https://t.co/5e7Pbxy7Z1, @jocelyndawson71 @h82w8md @gfosado @c4disc @WEsurvey
— sspilka (@sspilka) October 14, 2019
#TriangleSCI The Labor of Open … our morning team time was very productive! pic.twitter.com/zdNcO5DJGt
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 14, 2019
Working through lots of ideas @TriangleSCI with @dm_cooper @lisalibrarian @lesliekwchan @edrabinski and Ela Przybylo. #TriangleSCI #LaborofOpen #jojodoodles #scholarled #openaccess #publishing pic.twitter.com/3MrJ1KSIOg
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 14, 2019
Stopped by #TriangleSCI for a bit to hang with @edrabinski, @CharlotteRock, and @AprilHathcock & meet some new folks.
(I hope I’ll see you all again before you go!) pic.twitter.com/KBY2obb2ST
— Dr. Gibson (@AmeliaNGibson) October 14, 2019
Yeeeeees this is exactly what I want! #TriangleSCI https://t.co/u9x57XsoXY
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 14, 2019
Storyboarding our "The Labor of Open" zine. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/uA7czdZtgL
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 14, 2019
After lunch walk in the beautiful weather at the @RizzoCenter at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/Er9W7zLgWR
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 14, 2019
Working on bringing equity & diversity to peer review, with @ruthgibendi on the screen from Kenya and @YawBediako_ @I_Vinodh @ameliazein @Neurosarda & @richabdill in the room at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/mxxXwXGUrE
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 14, 2019
The Labor of Open team @lesliekwchan @edrabinski @jojokarlin @przybylo_ela @dm_cooper @lisalibrarian taking a break from storyboarding at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/jSgAaiTGMI
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 14, 2019
What a beautiful day here in Chapel Hill to be discussing issues of equity in scholarship with such great people at #TriangleSCI 2019. I feel so lucky. pic.twitter.com/NQWhDp0eLk
— Daniela Saderi, PhD (@Neurosarda) October 14, 2019
Labor of Open zine coming together at #TriangleSCI. pic.twitter.com/2R55lTLES4
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 14, 2019
Calling out the scholcomm patriarchy with @gimenadelr @AprilHathcock @CopyrightLady @FarbThink #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/b84Vs05ngX
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 14, 2019
Read about the #FeministToolkit here: https://t.co/ZHStj0aAmM #TriangleSCI
— OSU Copyright (@OSUCopyright) October 14, 2019
I survived 36-hour flight (including transit) and it’s all more than worth it. I enjoyed every bit of it❤️ thank you, team!😊 #TriangleSCI https://t.co/OACstzdeQ9
— Rizqy Amelia Zein (@ameliazein) October 14, 2019
Duke of Duke University made his fortune on tobacco. The campus is going smoke free next year.#TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/HX1W43Ljbt
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 14, 2019
Tour of @DukeU with #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/0Je9OVdaIt
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 15, 2019
Dinner at @DosPerrosDurham after touring Duke’s West Campus with #TriangleSCI. Tacos anyone? pic.twitter.com/7bw5oLNEpP
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 15, 2019
While I get the pushback, I also think this is a prime moment in scholarly communications to be re-thinking, re-defining, and re-framing the word "capital." #TriangleSCI
— Patricia Hswe (@pmhswe) October 15, 2019
I'm going along happily thinking about the problem of, say, vertically-integrated Elsevier products, and then I start thinking about the forces that produce a demand for such products and then I get totally overwhelmed and want to watch baseball instead. #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 15, 2019
The kernel of the idea that would become @HuMetricsHSS was developed as @rrkennison @jasonrhody @terrainsvagues @simosacchi, @skonkiel & I circled around this fountain & considered how to reverse engineer metrics so we measure what we value, rather than value what we measure.
— Chris Long (@cplong) October 15, 2019
@edrabinski I mentioned this @lesliekwchan article to you yesterday but @pmhswe I think you would like it too!https://t.co/AZDMYjbCKw #TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 15, 2019
mind = blown. So grateful for this chance to learn more from and with @lesliekwchan! #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 15, 2019
Loving open working with @przybylo_ela @lesliekwchan @dm_cooper @lisalibrarian @edrabinski. Thank you, @TriangleSCI @MellonFdn, for the opportunity. #TriangleSCI #jojodoodles pic.twitter.com/z9uoE4BHLY
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 15, 2019
Loved this article! I’m having some serious #TriangleSCI fomo this year.
— Nicky Agate (@terrainsvagues) October 15, 2019
Day 2. @TriangleSCI The Labor of #Open #Drawing #Ideas #Equity #Zines #DIY #OpenAccess #Communities #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/ON4MmGEvxZ
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 15, 2019
One of the many joys of @TriangleSCI is meeting amazing people from around the world including @YawBediako_ #TriangleSCI #Equity #Diversity #shoes pic.twitter.com/lBiSD0igy5
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 15, 2019
The prompt: The Labor of Open
The results from my team#TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/bXCuAJqIei— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 15, 2019
Communicating TEI to a multicultural user community Team @TriangleSCI @gimenadelr @hcayless @ldmm @knagasaki @MartinaScholger Helena Bermudez-Sabel #Equity #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/ToFjt7RYDz
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 15, 2019
I mean, if the problem was Elsevier, we could solve it by solving for Elsevier. But it's not like the world is different if it's called Stanford, or Drabinski Publishing, or if the profit was in different pockets. A different transformation is necessary. #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 15, 2019
Learning much from the international perspectives in the room. US folks (like me) have dangerous problem of acute parochialism combined with outsized access to resources that let us set agendas. #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 15, 2019
Team working on a zine about "the labor of open" leading a discussion at the first plenary at #TriangleSCI Remembering that the language we use may not work for all contexts, and that international perspectives must be taken into account. pic.twitter.com/soVvX7b2HA
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 15, 2019
Visual representation of the conversation, at the end of the first plenary discussion at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/o2zG6pxvdg
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 15, 2019
Taking a walk after lunch in the Dubose House gardens at the @RizzoCenter during a break from #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/WyNQlwDj7v
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 15, 2019
Hi from #TriangleSCI and @FarbThink's shoes pic.twitter.com/tDDh44mmk8
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 15, 2019
@TriangleSCI presenting our Toolkits for Equity plan and hoping to get lots of feedback from fellow TSCI participants pic.twitter.com/ViwIidqWD4
— sspilka (@sspilka) October 15, 2019
@YawBediako_ : In this room we're all aware of the inequities. So your problem is not whether *we* will use it, your question is how will you get it used by people who need it.
(because scholarly publishing is over 90% white) #TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 15, 2019
@FarbThink wonders if there could be structural targets
I believe @BeaconPressBks has undergone white supremacy education and has a target of 50% minority representation in their staff.#TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 15, 2019
Charlotte Roh comments “I think very important U.S. + Western Publishers acknowledge systemic racism + inequities caused by this structure/system on writing + scholarship around the world. @TriangleSCI #racism #bias #TriangleSCI #equity
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 15, 2019
@lesliekwchan calls toolkit out as a technical fix for the political problem of colonialism.#TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/oBc31XKgwl
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 15, 2019
Corrections: "Toolkits can't fix it (colonialism and white supremacy)" But as @AprilHathcock aptly noted, for the publishing industry that is still overwhelming white and blind to equity issue, it is at least a start.
— Leslie Chan (@lesliekwchan) October 16, 2019
Can you imagine if @aupresses @ScholarlyPub stood up and said, Our systems are harmful, don't copy them.
!!!#TriangleSCI https://t.co/eYHByUXGWF
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 15, 2019
Listening to what @CharlotteRock has had to say about white supremacy and racism in conference hotels has fundamentally changed the way I understand my own position as a white librarian so one suggestion would be to listen to @CharlotteRock. #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 15, 2019
Louis Round Wilson Library Special Collections @WilsonLibUNC @UNCLibrary @TriangleSCI #TriangleSCI #Equity #DismantleWhiteSupremacy pic.twitter.com/o5tYjiQBVb
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 15, 2019
Tour of UNC Chapel Hill includes site where Confederate statue was torn down and the counterpoint sculpture, the Unsung Founder's Monument #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/03Q8HLDPDn
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 15, 2019
It was great to hang out with #TriangleSCI crew! I see u @AprilHathcock @dm_cooper @lesliekwchan @FarbThink pic.twitter.com/i5UEFG0bFv
— Elaine L Westbrooks (@UNC_Librarian) October 16, 2019
Following #force2019 stream from afar. Lots of exciting projects around #openscience. Meanwhile I'm at the #TriangleSCI discussing with an awesome international team equity in scholarship and how "open by default" is NOT always an equitable solution. 1/3
— Daniela Saderi, PhD (@Neurosarda) October 16, 2019
Cultural contexts should be always considered when designing open, "innovative" alternatives to the broken status quo, and diverse voices should be leading the change. 1 solution fits all will perpetuate the same inequalities favoring the usual suspects. #TriangleSCI 3/3
— Daniela Saderi, PhD (@Neurosarda) October 16, 2019
Yes, yes, and yes! We tried to reflect on this @OCSDNet and with this manifesto https://t.co/Kk4OGlVR4t
— Leslie Chan (@lesliekwchan) October 16, 2019
The big question we're addressing at #TriangleSCI this week with our toolkits for #equity project… https://t.co/5qUGEmQ4Qw
— Jocelyn Dawson (@jocelyndawson71) October 16, 2019
We have much less expertise in making big collective social change. Other people have that expertise. How did @AOC build the necessary power to boot a longtime Democratic party machine dude and fundamentally change public conversations about justice? #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 16, 2019
Etc. etc. etc. I'm no expert either. But I think we need that expertise in our rooms if we want to transform scholcomm in structural ways. And maybe we don't really want to do that, but we keep telling each other that we do. #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 16, 2019
Equity and Diversity in Peer Review team presentation, really excited by the international representation on this team #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/LQMr9cSdaB
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
Whew. Calling out that the #openaccess movement is based in the Global North and the ppl repping it look the same. Is it just the same in different clothes? #TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
Focused on research practice and dissemination bc the team is made of biomedical scientists who like evidence-based analysis. 🤣#TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/2ocPxIWvaE
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
There are lots of more specific studies on the inequities of peer review, but I like to point to the report @publons put out on the global state of peer review for last year's peer review week: https://t.co/IBqMjRegQy
Yes, there's a peer review week. #TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
Starting discussion with the Equity and Diversity in Peer Review team at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/KYBRWX07fD
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
The #open movement remains dominated by a global minority in the global north. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/shgRWdorx8
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
Suggestion from @paoloman at #TriangleSCI that we often think of each phase as a filtering or even hazing process (keep the bad ones out) but we should instead make each phase about mentoring and improving. pic.twitter.com/iFb14wZz6l
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
Introducing a Feminist Framework for Radical Knowledge Collaboration! A work in progress. Pls comment & engage. #TriangleSCI https://t.co/le6VPd1iWD @gimenadelr @CharlotteRock @CopyrightLady @ivonnelujano @FarbThink pic.twitter.com/VPyF85yr9L
— APRIL (@AprilHathcock) October 16, 2019
Preparing to #BreakTheWheel of global north publication cycle at #TriangleSCI so scholarship can be made, understand, and valued in terms of community impact in local and global communities. 🐉🔥🔓
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
“Is the goal of scientific research to be published in journals or is the goal to reach + inform communities impacted?” @YawBediako_ @TriangleSCI #PeerReviewTeam #TriangleSCI #inequities #diversity #communities #OpenAccess pic.twitter.com/sEjg7vjF0E
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 16, 2019
Reminder from @h82w8md that we need a Phase 5 for communicating scholarship to the public in ways that can actuallybe understood and used. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/469z1lsgHr
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
More information and context on the history of peer review and the potential for change in this special issue mentioned at #TriangleSCI https://t.co/gxM1rKd1dm
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
Also #TriangleSCI notes great work done by @CharlotteRock on the role of editors: https://t.co/nCoGTWBpEt
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
Adding #TriangleSCI. https://t.co/VlX1J1bLNN
— Patricia Hswe (@pmhswe) October 16, 2019
#TriangleSCI https://t.co/Wm9u2e6o8G
— Patricia Hswe (@pmhswe) October 16, 2019
Here's the preprint link! https://t.co/FHwBeC3QL8#TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
This morning’s #TriangleSCI plenary about Equity in Scholarly Peer Review – @Neurosarda @ameliazein @YawBediako_ @richabdill @I_Vinodh and Ruth – encourages us all to build trust and community. #jojodoodles pic.twitter.com/zuvNj1mEtA
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 16, 2019
We keep bumping up against the same block in these conversations: how do we make actual change? This is the expertise we're missing that social movements have. Get them in the room with us, if they're willing! #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 16, 2019
Starting a discussion about communicating TEI to a multilingual user community at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/zwFT0Co9K4
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
Also on a more positive note, an example of purposeful change in peer review: https://t.co/Wcy90NMU5U#TriangleSCI h/t @ScholarlyPub @theAGU
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
TEI team notes that their team composition reflects the growth of #DH as a particularly global movement doing both literal and cultural translation. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/KzAwWYeogb
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
Specific examples of #TEI in Japan and Germany with unique issues met by growing local communities. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/PbMWodQIiY
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
"Mandatory when applicable" is such a fantastic phrase. Thanks for sharing this TEI team! I understand it but it also makes me laugh! #TriangleSCI
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 16, 2019
Really appreciate the team presenting on "Communicating the TEI to a Multilingual User Community" raising specific examples of translation challenges—e.g., "chunk": How do you convey the meaning of this word in other languages? #TriangleSCI
— Patricia Hswe (@pmhswe) October 16, 2019
.@gimenadelr also points out the challenges of teaching TEI in languages other than English—e.g., the need to translate the terms from English to Spanish on the spot. #TriangleSCI
— Patricia Hswe (@pmhswe) October 16, 2019
Here are the ACRL policies/procedures for translating ACRL docs into languages other than English – https://t.co/679QEAzFDX #TriangleSCI
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 16, 2019
Here are the IFLA language policies. (With apologies that I mis-remembered a few details and/or its been updated since I last read. E.g., Chinese is one of the languages.) https://t.co/bV32Xp3Ikp #TriangleSCI
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 16, 2019
Nicole Coggins of UVA Press making a really important point to include Indigenous languages when addressing the internationalization of TEI. #TriangleSCI
— Patricia Hswe (@pmhswe) October 16, 2019
Second plenary on #TEI translation!@gimenadelr @hcayless @MartinaScholger Helena @knagasaki @ldmm at @TriangleSCI #TriangleSCI #jojodoodles pic.twitter.com/1wJWOqmhnS
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 16, 2019
Been following #TriangleSCI conversations in parallel – seeing a thought convergence here 👇 https://t.co/ThzxUM2u4N
— Emmy Tsang (@emmy_ft) October 16, 2019
Starting discussion about the Feminist Framework for Radical Knowledge Collaboration with @AprilHathcock and a set of framing questions at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/UhBDe1PG3z
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
Comments coming in. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/3Hn7gDh4ei
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 16, 2019
#TriangleSCI reading responses to 3 questions
1. How has the patriarchy affected you?
2. How has the patriarchy affected your work?
3. How are you complicit in the patriarchy? pic.twitter.com/pQxJOZh6og— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
We moved from a living toolkit to a living process, from a manifesto to a femifesto. @gimenadelr@FarbThink #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/ILPt2A8Gvb
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
@AprilHathcock @CopyrightLady describing the Femifesto Overarching Principles, which are reflected throughout the document.#TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/6KNk5tghlE
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
Really good engagement and people's ideas and concerns aligning with our own.#TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/qpVZozGGRV
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
So much of #TriangleSCI has been about the importance of connections, relationships, thick commitments to each other. I’m so on board with this, and usefully prompted to look around and name my comrades, see who’s missing.
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 16, 2019
Really appreciating the Femifesto, a framework for radical knowledge collaboration… Love the emphasis on intersectionality, trust, power, and more #TriangleSCI by @AprilHathcock @gimenadelr @CharlotteRock @CopyrightLady @ivonnelujano @FarbThink 👇🏼👇🏽👇🏿 https://t.co/QSCxGwFRXR
— Daniela Saderi, PhD (@Neurosarda) October 16, 2019
Amazing work by my #TriangleSCI colleagues. Practice that I need to implement: "Allowing for slowness in the work can be a radical act." https://t.co/hNtuvSLG9f
— Jocelyn Dawson (@jocelyndawson71) October 16, 2019
My thanks to @AprilHathcock @gimenadelr @CopyrightLady @ivonnelujano @FarbThink for allowing me to bring my whole self to #TriangleSCI, which in fact was my absent self, since I was on maternity leave this year, and for allowing me that space and care. pic.twitter.com/N56pe7ylHT
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
Toolkits for Equity team leading a plenary conversation at #TriangleSCI yesterday afternoon. pic.twitter.com/R72ecg7zyL
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 16, 2019
Tour of @UNC with #TriangleSCI Tuesday evening, led by @jesherer from @uncpressblog pic.twitter.com/yCHLzJCdNq
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 16, 2019
Bringing Equity and Diversity to Peer Review team leading a conversation at #TriangleSCI with @ruthgibendi joining online from Kenya. pic.twitter.com/6jbjoltVY2
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 16, 2019
Communicating the TEI to a Multilingual User Community team discussing challenges of translating text encoding documentation at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/Dd4Tb1ANcE
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 16, 2019
Lunch at the @RizzoCenter Dubose House for #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/SfR1nOcOPp
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 16, 2019
#TriangleSCI at work pic.twitter.com/BBL34iWA6l
— sspilka (@sspilka) October 16, 2019
Material production process …. the zine is made. #triangleSCI #thelaborofopen pic.twitter.com/T9e0GXc6BQ
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 16, 2019
Developing a Feminist Framework for Radical Knowledge Collaboration at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/cYEhSWYHGd
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 16, 2019
. @jojokarlin illustrating the zine for The Labor of Open team at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/Nm9qtStZi5
— ScholComm Institute (@TriangleSCI) October 16, 2019
The third plenary today: Feminist Framework for Radical Knowledge Collaboration. @AprilHathcock @CharlotteRock @CopyrightLady @FarbThink @gimenadelr #TriangleSCI #jojodoodles pic.twitter.com/KcOpd9ndVO
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 16, 2019
@gimenadelr @FarbThink @CharlotteRock @CopyrightLady @AprilHathcock #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/G8eL9sYegw
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 16, 2019
#TriangleSCI touring the Hunt Library @ncsulibraries pic.twitter.com/32xmKm24Xp
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
Whew, I give up. pic.twitter.com/VGY6e7pZZB
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 16, 2019
With a beautiful logo by @h82w8md , our #TriangleSCI project is feeling real. Looking forward to the next phase. pic.twitter.com/WAr4xcTzcd
— Jocelyn Dawson (@jocelyndawson71) October 17, 2019
Starting the last day at #TriangleSCI with the Toolkits for Equity team. pic.twitter.com/Chr5anvX5m
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Report out day at Triangle SCI! So excited to see the great, important work these teams have built. #trianglesci pic.twitter.com/RfHEOvYmWS
— Micah Vandegrift (@micahvandegrift) October 17, 2019
The team created three Toolkits for antiracism in publishing. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/fThZACQc4s
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Just discovered that @jocelyndawson71 from the Toolkits for Equity team attended my @ScholarlyPub meeting panel a couple years ago, where I had everyone count the white people in the room.
One of my favorite exercises! #TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 17, 2019
When I first attended the @ScholarlyPub meeting five years ago, there was absolutely no awareness of racism as an issue in the industry. There's a lot more to do, but I'm hopeful that we've come this far already. #TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 17, 2019
One of the first slides from today’s #TriangleSCI report-outs is a summary of new anti-racism tool kit for scholarly publishing (an industry that is 90% white) pic.twitter.com/06RPcTCpye
— John Sherer (@jesherer) October 17, 2019
“Inspired by @AAMers Toolkits for Transgender Inclusion in the Workplace we created 3 toolkits to address inequities in scholarly communications” @TriangleSCI Toolkits for Equity Team #TriangleSCI #Equity pic.twitter.com/j6KO966drA
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 17, 2019
Whew these examples of experiences on the screen. Publishing is horrible for people of color, y'all.#TriangleSCI https://t.co/Ux3PwvCELi
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 17, 2019
“Feminist Framework for Radical Knowledge Collaboration” #Femifesto #TriangleSCI @gimenadelr @CopyrightLady @FarbThink @CharlotteRock @ivonnelujano https://t.co/JEqtN0Zrnr
— APRIL (@AprilHathcock) October 17, 2019
Thank you @jesherer for saying:
I don't need a forum. I get to speak whenever I want as a white man. I assume I can be heard. Center the voices of people of color, not mine.#TriangleSCI
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 17, 2019
I love the tangible output from the Labor of Open group. Proud to have been invited to print the 1st color version! #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/h5RAXUGc8v
— Micah Vandegrift (@micahvandegrift) October 17, 2019
The Labor of Open team begins their discussion with a zine on their topic. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/gwvHf7FxUh
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Check out the full zine made at #TriangleSCI here: https://t.co/uvjdmiEsUw
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Love that this #TriangleSCI team created a print publication, but also the metadata and multiple versions for digital access @ManifoldScholar https://t.co/ZfeOdB0jfB
— John Sherer (@jesherer) October 17, 2019
Toolkits for Equity: Transforming Scholarly Publishing Communities presents their first toolkit! @gfosado @h82w8md @sspilka @jocelyndawson71 and Niccole #TriangleSCI #jojodoodles pic.twitter.com/wQHH69HRFn
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 17, 2019
Loving Ela's comment: "The zine is an unpretentious format." Yes, exactly! #TriangleSCI #TheLaborOfOpen https://t.co/XLLzzfc64v
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 17, 2019
Femifesto team begins with critical questions and positioning at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/EMpcgYkAp1
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Read more about the project developed at #TriangleSCI in this blog post: https://t.co/U8O0fIWWSD
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Femifesto areas of concentration: 1) Building empowering relationships, 2) Developing anti-oppressive description and metadata, and 3) Engaging in ethical and inclusive dissemination and publication. #TriangleSCI
— UNCScholComm (@UNCScholComm) October 17, 2019
I want to acknowledge that @AprilHathcock did SO MUCH of the actual writing on this.
Really impressed by her writing, so often her first draft was the final draft.#TriangleSCI https://t.co/a9HSTDn3Wp
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 17, 2019
Important to be reminded at #TriangleSCI that North Carolina's statutes on bathrooms are an obstacle to full participation in scholarly communications. Thank you @CharlotteRock @FarbThink
— John Sherer (@jesherer) October 17, 2019
The Peer Review team disassembled the research production process to identify inequities. #TriangleSCI
— Micah Vandegrift (@micahvandegrift) October 17, 2019
@ivonnelujano @virbrussa @rominickyDL @yoko_nh @natcorbe este es el Femifesto que trabajamos en #TriangleSCI con @AprilHathcock @CopyrightLady @CharlotteRock @FarbThink nos ayudan a diseminar y/o traducir? https://t.co/dNT4titoHU
— Gimena del Rio Riande 💚 (@gimenadelr) October 17, 2019
The only thing better than reading @AprilHathcock is having her read it out loud in a room #TriangleSCI https://t.co/k24WV5jfM2
— John Sherer (@jesherer) October 17, 2019
All Kenyan universities pooled their resources to get shared access to Elsevier journals and it wasn’t enough. No researchers in Kenya can access Elsevier journals without another way in through a collaborator or other affiliation. @YawBediako_ #TriangleSCI
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 17, 2019
Listening to @YawBediako_ talk about the challenges of scholars getting access to ELS journals in Africa and wondering how scholars there perceive Germany, CA, etc. "doing without" … but then having doc delivery, ILL, etc. The privilege of choosing to do without? #triangleSCI
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 17, 2019
Peer review team ended up looking at the whole cycle of research & publication. Realizations: The cycle is not linear and inequities pervade every phase of the cycle. Openness is not necessarily the solution all the time. #TriangleSCI
— UNCScholComm (@UNCScholComm) October 17, 2019
Equity in Peer Review team at #TriangleSCI introducing the team, which was built intentionally to reflect a diverse, global scholarly system. pic.twitter.com/zIavT1W5sa
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Listening to the peer review team today and earlier has led me to think a lot about how access to mentoring and feedback is in itself a privilege not available to everyone. #TriangleSCI
— UNCScholComm (@UNCScholComm) October 17, 2019
@Celeste_Box mirá lo que hicimos con @AprilHathcock @FarbThink @CharlotteRock @CopyrightLady en #TriangleSCI. Te sumás al grupo? Podemos diseminar/traducir/remixar por ARG? https://t.co/dNT4titoHU
— Gimena del Rio Riande 💚 (@gimenadelr) October 17, 2019
“Provide a room and snacks.” @YawBediako_ boils things down. #buildingtrust #conversation #TriangleSCI
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 17, 2019
The conversation is strong between, across groups, even though we’re most of us meeting for the first time here. Too true, @CopyrightLady! Thank you, @TriangleSCI, @MellonFdn, for bringing people into the room. #TriangleSCI
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 17, 2019
"You also have to feed your family at the end of the day so maybe just being an equal participant is enough."
– @lisalibrarianI mean, everyone in this room is doing at least 2 jobs, right?#TriangleSCI
— Charlotte Rock (@CharlotteRock) October 17, 2019
My pondering re if a choice has to be made between working to participate equally in an existing system and working to overthrow the system in order to replace it. Or, can the first lead to transformation, i.e. to the the second? I don't know. #TriangleSCI https://t.co/VqPg43vWqj
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 17, 2019
Something I’ve always loved about #TriangleSCI is the proximity it gives to #DigitalHumanities, #openscience, publishing, and #scholcomm. We’ve seen representations of each of these in the groups this morning. A question – what’s our big umbrella and how do we build on that?
— Micah Vandegrift (@micahvandegrift) October 17, 2019
TEI for a Multilingual Community team introducing the complexity of translation and need for better, more international guidelines and specifications at #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/0zj4aJUm1j
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Communicating the TEI to a Multicultural User Community Team @TriangleSCI proposes internationalization to @TEIconsortium as next steps #TriangleSCI #Equity #Multilingual pic.twitter.com/tLffaDy1qr
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 17, 2019
Looking at increasing equity through translation of the #TEI guidelines. @hcayless @knagasaki @MartinaScholger @gimenadelr and Helena present. #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/9pflROLB5G
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 17, 2019
From one of the many great teams presenting at #TriangleSCI today…"Bringing Equity to Peer Review" highlight inequities at ever phase of the research process (such as lack of access to mentors) pic.twitter.com/Z4PWz93ajL
— James Sponsel (@jqsponsel) October 17, 2019
Just reading in more detail the Feministo framework from #TriangleSCI – so beautifully written. The emphasis on slow, careful, inclusive progress is *so* powerful and moving ❤️ Everyone working towards making the 🌏better needs to read this. https://t.co/Z4OE8VYTkP
— Emmy Tsang (@emmy_ft) October 17, 2019
At the close of #TriangleSCI, very grateful for the support of @MellonFdn, brilliant new colleagues from the week, and all the people that put @TriangleSCI together, especially @paoloman.
— Jocelyn Dawson (@jocelyndawson71) October 17, 2019
Highlighting for #force2019 attendees: the #triangleSCI conference earlier this week was themed about equity in scholarly communications & we should all look at these outputs. I hope they'll be summarised at https://t.co/IpYHStX37K in due course, as well as being shared via the # https://t.co/9CvCAjZZKc
— Naomi Penfold (@npscience) October 17, 2019
Brainstorming future @TriangleSCI. Why don’t we have satellites in Ghana, India, Chicago, etc? #TriangleSCI #OpenitUP #OpenAccess #Equity #International pic.twitter.com/y2f0OF8L10
— Sharon E. Farb (@FarbThink) October 17, 2019
Thanks to everyone for an amazing #TriangleSCI 2019! Learned so much and so excited to see these projects and communities continue to move forward. pic.twitter.com/jnnkxDKHPc
— Will Cross (@tceles_B_hsup) October 17, 2019
Omg. @CharlotteRock @lesliekwchan are two of my faves!! Thank you #TriangleSCI! pic.twitter.com/lBJwqOF973
— Emily Drabinski (@edrabinski) October 17, 2019
Thank you, @TriangleSCI! #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/J1JTrQS9J6
— Jojo Karlin (@jojokarlin) October 17, 2019
Yaa and Yaw. Amazing to meet fellow Ghanaian and
brilliant @YawBediako_ . #TriangleSCI pic.twitter.com/39Bb3UN6B8— Copyright Lady (@CopyrightLady) October 17, 2019
#TheLaborOfOpen team appreciates the Labor(ers) of #TriangleSCI! https://t.co/GAq7Xu8c2c
— Lisa Janicke Hinchliffe (@lisalibrarian) October 17, 2019
Completely in favor of this idea. ✊ #Decentralization #TriangleSCI https://t.co/OJdXVPtUQ5
— Daniela Saderi, PhD (@Neurosarda) October 17, 2019
Leaving #TriangleSCI feeling grateful for the people I was able to meet and learn from in these past 4 days. Thank you @TriangleSCI for the wonderful job organizing this meeting, and thank you @MellonFdn for investing in people and free expression of ideas.
— Daniela Saderi, PhD (@Neurosarda) October 17, 2019
Thank u @YawBediako_, @ameliazein, @I_Vinodh, @richabdill, @ruthgibendi 4 being so respectful, open to listening to 1 another, & for sharing ur unique perspectives. I look forward to working with u all on next steps. Shutout to @dasaptaerwin 4 ur contribution w this 💯 drawing. pic.twitter.com/zObcIReTgV
— Daniela Saderi, PhD (@Neurosarda) October 17, 2019
To my friends from #TriangleSCI – thank you for being so generous with your time and your knowledge and your ideas. This was a great week together, and I learned so much. And as always thanks to the @MellonFdn and my @TriangleSCI colleagues for making this all possible. pic.twitter.com/o4Ed6QcDD8
— Paolo Mangiafico (@paoloman) October 17, 2019